top of page
  • Writer's pictureMatthew Lerner

What every startup gets wrong (and how to fix it)

As an early-stage VC, at every single pitch, I had to warn the confidence-drunk founders that they are probably wrong. (Like 99% chance they’re wrong, even if the pitch was great).


How did I know? Because pretty much every startup ever had the wrong initial hypothesis:

  • PayPal - The first use case was digital money transfers between Palm Pilots (a '90s handheld scheduling device).

  • Uber - Travis and Garret were both super rich before they founded Uber, so they first envisioned it as “NetJets for Limos,” with a fleet of S-Class Benz's.

  • AirBnB - VCs didn’t believe anyone would want to rent an air mattress in a grad student’s living room. (And they were right!) Look at AirBnB now, they mainly rent fancy vacation condos.

So if Elon Musk, Peter Thiel, Travis Kalanick, et. al. were wrong about their customers' needs… tell me again, why is it that you’re so confident you’re right?


The upshot here: What all three of these companies did insanely well was to listen to the market, notice where they were getting pulled, pivot towards the legitimate demand, and then go all-in.


Until customers are biting your hand off, treat your core proposition as a hypothesis, keep gathering info and refining it.


A More Actionable Example

These examples are obvious in hindsight, but not so much in the “heat of battle.” Thankfully, my friend Robert Desmond wrote a great first-hand account of his recent pivot at his latest startup Leadsie.

548 views0 comments

Recent Posts

See All

Imagine if everyone in your startup consolidated their 2024 goals into a single list. How long would it be? If it’s longer than 3 items, keep reading. There’s a pattern in the early days of any great

If I told you a B2B business had 90% customer churn, would you invest? What if I told you they gross $28B and have a 10-year CAGR of 16%? So how can such a strong business have 90% customer churn? Her

What I learned from Wise's first Head of Growth Transferwise (now Wise) grew from zero to $1B in revenue in the past 10 years in a very competitive market. How did they find their big growth lever bac

bottom of page